Superhero Grief and the Multiverse of Loss
Considerations and Case Studies in Non-Death Losses
Grief is not only about death.
The pain of divorce, illness, estrangement, addiction, job loss, and futures that never unfold is real, and it deserves to be recognized.
Edited by Jill A. Harrington, DSW, LCSW & Darcy L. Harris, PhD, RN, RSW, FT
Routledge Publishing
ABOUT THE BOOK
Superhero Grief and the Multiverse of Loss explores the unseen grief people carry: the pain of non-death losses such as divorce, illness, disability, job loss, identity change, estrangement, relocation, addiction, mental illness, betrayal, and the loss of future hopes and dreams.
Drawing on powerful metaphors from modern superhero narratives, the book shows that grief arises not only after the death of a loved one, but also from the tangible and intangible losses of everyday life. Through case studies and practical insights, it validates grief that others may not recognize and offers strategies for coping.
Each of us has a hero’s journey through loss. This book offers readers the hope of finding a way forward.
WHO IT’S FOR
Clinicians and counselors
Case-based frameworks and practical strategies for supporting clients with disenfranchised, ambiguous, and non-finite losses.
Educators and students
Memorable stories that make grief theory accessible for courses in counseling, social work, psychology, nursing, and thanatology.
People living with loss
Language and perspective for grief that others may not understand, and the reassurance that your loss counts.
WHAT’S INSIDE
35 chapters across 11 sections, written by clinicians, scholars, educators, and people with lived experience. Chapters draw on Wanda Maximoff, Tony Stark, Black Panther, Thor, Wonder Woman, Batman, Captain America, Luke Skywalker, the Mandalorian, and many more.
Loss of Time and Control
Relational Losses
Losses of Health, Function, and Ability
Navigating Difference
Transgenerational Loss
Loss of Beliefs, Purpose, and Meaning
Superhero Identity and Childhood Trauma
Loss of Homeland and Environment
Mental Health, Addiction, and Loss
What people are saying about Superhero Grief and the Multiverse of Loss
Dedication
To my son, Alex, who taught me about the spectrum of life and my ability to adapt. To my daughter, Madeline, my tiny fighter, who has taught me to remain steadfast in the face of uncertainty. To my stepchildren, Jax and Mari, who remind me that in life there is always room for growth. To my sponsor midshipmen, Cameron and Alex, who helped me restore a meaningful bond. To my husband, David, who has reaffirmed that change is not always an ending, but an invitation to begin again.
-JAH
For Brad and Lauren — whose love is my anchor in an ever-changing world.
-DLH
-
Introduction: The Echo of Non-Death Loss: A Personal Story
Cody Thomas Blackbird
Part I: Framing the Work
1.It’s Not All About Thanos – Loss Comes in Many Forms
Darcy L. Harris and Jill A. Harrington
Part II: Loss of Time and Control
2. Personal Blips: Re-emerging from a Loss of Time
Pamela A. Malone and Jill A. Harrington
3. Inability to Change the Past: Loss of Control and Lessons from the Flash and Doctor Strange
Jill A. Harrington, Sharon Strouse, and Kim Burditt Bartlett
4. Thor: The Importance of Self-forgiveness in the Face of Failure
Jakob van Wielink and Leo Wilhelm
5. Non-Death Loss and the Human Condition: The Hulk, Autism, and Mental Health in Conversation
Sara Pula and Alexander D. LaMorie
Part III: Relational Losses
6. Lucifer: Bringing Light to Loss from Family Estrangement
Jill A. Harrington, Pamela A. Malone, and Debi Jenkins Frankle
7. The Avengers: Loss of Friendship and Trust in a Team
Marnix Reijmerink and Jakob van Wielink
8. Guardians of the Galaxy: The Quest for Calling in the Face of Loss of Belonging
Leo Wilhelm and Jakob van Wielink
9. Black Panther: Losing Faith in Our Fathers
Greg Adams
10. Divorce, Children, and Non-Custodial Parents: Ant-Man and the Quantum Realm of Loss
Jill A. Harrington and Ami Neiberger
11. Luke Skywalker: Adopted Children —Feeling Loved, Feeling Loss
Jill A. Harrington, Karen McSweeney, and Teresa E. Doniger
Part IV: Navigating Losses of Health, Function, Ability
12. Unveiling Stark’s Heart: Loss and Living with Chronic Illness
Debi Jenkins Frankle
13. Hands of a Surgeon: Dr. Stephen Strange and Professional Identity Loss
Noah M. Raizman
14. Black Widow and Non-Death Loss: Bodily Autonomy and Forced Sterilization
Brooke Baker, MacKenzie A. Kibler, and E. Goldblatt Hyatt
15. Professor X and Wolverine: Navigating the Journey of Loss Due to Dementia
Shannon A. Matthews
Part V: Navigating Difference
16. Drax and the Loss of Metaphors - Autism, Grief, and a Parent’s Journey: A Conversation with Jill A. Harrington
Rebecca Morse, Kailey Bradley, and Jill A. Harrington
17. Mutation, Loss, Community, and Love: Non-Finite Losses in the LGBTQ Community
Bradford Leary
Part VI: Transgenerational Loss
18. Zuri's Legacy: Healing Transgenerational Grief and Loss through Spiritual Practice
Raé N. Lundy
19. Luke Cage: Giving Power to the Silenced Grief of Incarceration Loss
Reverend Eric Brewer
20. Journey to Captain America and the Double Consciousness of African American Patriotism
Jillian M. Blueford and Kertesha B. Riley
Part VII: Loss of Beliefs, Purpose, and Meaning
21. Exploring Complex Relational and Spiritual Loss in Superhero Narratives
Brendan Prout
22. Okoye: Lessons from a Warrior on Job Loss, Identity, and Disparities
Jasmine Cobb
23. Loss of A Balanced Life: Am I Wearing the Mask or is It Wearing Me?
Kent Tonkin
24. What Captain America Teaches Us About Non-death Loss and Positive Coping with Grief
Paul T. Bartone and David F. Carey
Part VIII: Superhero Identity and Childhood Trauma
25. Unraveling the Scarlet Threads: Displaced Children, Grief, and What We Can Learn from Wanda Maximoff's Journey
Donna A. Gaffney
26. Shadows in Context: Two-Face, Batman, and Losses Associated with a Traumatic Childhood
Mark Shelvock
27. America Chavez: Navigating Betrayal Trauma, Intersectionality, and Resilience in the Multiverse of Loss
Lauren Cortéz and Diane Diaz
28. The Mandalorian and Fear of Attachment: Loss of the Mask – Din Djarin Allows Himself to Be Seen
Sharon Strouse and Jill A. Harrington
Part IX: Loss of Homeland/Environment
29. The Asian Experiences of Non-Death Loss and the Last Airbender
Yong Hao Ng
30. Wayne Manor and Rebuilding Your Life After the Loss of Your Home
Lindsey Whissel Fenton
31. Wonder Woman: Chosen Migration and Inhabiting a Liminal Space
Maria Georgopoulos and R. Abby Spilka
32. From Poison Ivy to the Justice League: A Psychological Approach to Environmental and Political Grief
Mark Shelvock
Part X: Mental Health, Addiction, and Loss
33. Addiction and Ambiguous Loss: Tony Stark's Long-Lasting Struggles
Laura Vargas
34. Lost to the Darkness: Wanda Maximoff and the Non-Death Losses of Mental Illness Cheryl H. Dodson and Jill A. Harrington
Part XI: Conclusion
35. Conclusion: From the Multiverse of Loss to Empowerment
Jill A. Harrington -
Greg Adams. Ch. 9
Brooke Baker. Ch. 14
Kim Burditt Bartlett. Ch. 3
Paul T. Bartone, PhD, Visiting Research Fellow at the Institute for National Security Policy, National Defense University. Ch. 24
Cody Thomas Blackbird. Introduction
Jillian M. Blueford. Ch. 20
Kailey Bradley. Ch. 16
Reverend Eric Brewer, DMin, Director of Field Education and Program Coordinator of the Black Church Resource Center, School of Divinity, Howard University. Ch. 19
David F. Carey, MS, BS, LTC, U.S. Army (Retired), Combat-Veteran (OIF/OEF); National Security Contractor, U.S. Department of Defense.* Ch. 24
Jasmine Cobb. Ch. 22
Lauren Cortéz. Ch. 27
Diane Diaz. Ch. 27
Cheryl Hogsten Dodson, DNP, MBA, RN, CCM, Assistant Professor of Nursing, Department of Nursing, Methodist University.* Ch. 34
Teresa E. Doniger. Ch. 11
Lindsey Whissel Fenton, MEd, CT, grief educator and filmmaker; founder, Empathic Media. Ch. 30
Debi Jenkins Frankle, MS, LMFT, Calabasas Counseling and Grief Center; founder, Private Practice Grief Workshops and Trainings for Mental Health Clinicians. Chs. 6, 12
Donna A. Gaffney, DNSc, FAAN, psychotherapist (specializing in loss, grief and trauma among children and families), educational consultant, and founder of DAGaffney Consulting LLC.* Ch. 25
Maria Georgopoulos. Ch. 31
Erica Goldblatt Hyatt, DSW, LCSW, MBE, Assistant Director of the DSW Program, Assistant Teaching Professor, School of Social Work, Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey.* Ch. 14
Jill A. Harrington, DSW, LCSW, former assistant professor of social work at Marymount University, and maintains a small private clinical practice. Lead Editor. Introduction and Chs. 1, 2, 3, 6, 10, 11, 16, 28, 34, 35
Darcy L. Harris, PhD, RN, RSW, FT, professor emeritus of thanatology at King’s University College at Western University, where she also maintains a private clinical practice. Co-Editor. Ch. 1
MacKenzie A. Kibler. Ch. 14
Alexander D. LaMorie, in loving memory. Ch. 5
Bradford Leary, LCSW, CT, clinical social worker in private practice. Ch. 17 [VERIFY]
Raé N. Lundy. Ch. 18
Pamela A. Malone, PhD, LCSW-S, FT, Assistant Professor-in-Practice, University of Texas at Arlington School of Social Work; Clinical Supervisor; Private Practice, Blue Lapis Consulting, PLLC.* Chs. 2, 6
Shannon A. Matthews. Ch. 15
Karen McSweeney. Ch. 11
Rebecca S. Morse, PhD, Associate Professor, Director of Research Training, Institute for Psychological Sciences, Divine Mercy University.* Ch. 16
Ami Neiberger. Ch. 10
Yong Hao Ng, PhD, MSocWk, Senior Tutor, Department of Social Work, National University of Singapore. Ch. 29
Brendan Prout, MDiv, CTC, CGC, CISR, Worship Pastor, Quest Church.* Ch. 21
Sara Pula. Ch. 5
Noah M. Raizman. Ch. 13
Marnix Reijmerink. Ch. 7
Kertesha B. Riley. Ch. 20
Mark Shelvock, MACP, MA, RP, registered psychotherapist; lecturer, Western University. Chs. 26, 32.
R. Abby Spilka. Ch. 31
Sharon Strouse, MA, ATR-BC, LCPAT, Associate Director, The Portland Institute for Loss and Transition; Private Practice, Art Therapist; Co-founder, The Kristin Rita Strouse Foundation.* Chs. 3, 28
Kent Tonkin. Ch. 23
Jakob van Wielink, MA, executive coach and partner, De School voor Transitie; faculty mentor, Portland Institute for Loss and Transition. Chs. 4, 7, 8
Laura Vargas, MSW, LCSW, founder, Vargas Counseling and Consulting, LLC; adjunct faculty, Graduate School of Social Work, University of Denver. Ch. 33
Leo Wilhelm, MSc, grief counselor, author, executive coach, and advisor to De School voor Transitie. Chs. 4, 8
-
Jill A. Harrington, DSW, LCSW is an Adjunct Professor for the Chicago School of Professional Psychology, Washington DC Campus as well as a Part-Time Lecturer for Rutgers University School of Social Work. Dr. Harrington also maintains an active clinical counseling practice in the Greater Washington DC Area. She earned her Doctorate in Social Work from The University of Pennsylvania School of Social Policy & Practice, Philadelphia, PA and is one of the first published authors on the subject of bereavement in U.S. military families. She has been a practicing social worker for over twenty years and has had a special focus on trauma, loss and bereavement. Dr. Harrington is a former Senior Director of Field Research for Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences (USUHS) Center for the Study of Traumatic Stress (CSTS), Bethesda, Maryland and has been a consultant to Columbia University Center for Complicated Grief. Dr. Harrington is active on many national and international committees and working groups, addressing bereavement, clinical practice and grief awareness and education. She is a member of The National Association of Social Workers, The American Association of Suicidology as well as a former Board Member (2011-2014) for the Association for Death Education & Counseling and currently serves as the Chair of the Conference Committee, Concurrent Program. In her career, she has published numerous peer-reviewed articles and book chapters. She is the creator and lead editor of the new, creative textbook, entitled, Superhero Grief: The Transformative Power of Loss (2021), published by Routledge.
Email: drjillharrington@gmail.com
Darcy L. Harris, RN, RSW, MEd (Couns), PhD, FT is Professor Emerita of Thanatology at King’s University College at Western University in London, Ontario, Canada, where she developed the undergraduate degree program in Thanatology, dedicated to the study of death, dying, and bereavement. Dr. Harris also maintains a private clinical practice specializing in issues related to change, loss, and transition. She began her career as a registered nurse, working for 15 years in oncology and hospice care before pursuing graduate training in counseling psychology and completing her doctoral studies in psychology and thanatology at Union Institute and University in Cincinnati, Ohio. She has dedicated her career to the study and clinical practice of grief and loss, with particular expertise in non-death losses, complicated grief, compassion-based approaches to grief therapy, and the social and cultural dimensions of bereavement. Dr. Harris is a faculty member of the Portland Institute for Loss and Transition, where she contributes to postgraduate training in grief therapy and Meaning Reconstruction in Loss. She has served on the Board of Directors of the Association for Death Education and Counseling and currently serves on the Board of Directors of the International Work Group on Death, Dying, and Bereavement. She is also a series co-editor for Routledge’s Death, Dying, and Bereavement Series and is an internationally recognized speaker, researcher, and author. Her publications include Counting Our Losses: Reflecting on Change, Loss, and Transition in Everyday Life (2010), Grief and Bereavement in Contemporary Society: Bridging Research and Practice (2011), Handbook of Social Justice in Loss and Grief (2016), Non-Death Loss and Grief: Context and Clinical Implications (2020), Principles and Practice of Grief Counseling (2021), and Compassion-Based Approaches in Loss and Grief (2023). Her research and writing continue to advance contemporary understandings of grief, emphasizing compassion, social justice, and the recognition of loss in its many forms.